Could be photo of John T. Duntlin?
What does Chatgpt think?


🕰The Studio: Dunshee’s New Photographic Parlor, 3 Tremont Row, Boston
“Dunshee’s Photographic Parlor” was run by Albert Southworth Dunshee.
His studio operated at 3 Tremont Row during the post–Civil War period.
Studios at Tremont Row were especially active around:
- 1865–1875 → peak years for cabinet cards and cartes-de-visite (CdVs).
📏 Card Style & Printing
The back design matches what was typical for early carte-de-visite backs:
- Cream-colored card stock
- Simple serif typography
- “Copies of the same at any time” (common 1860s–1870s advertisement line)
- Minimalistic layout before the ornate 1880s–1890s decorative backs became common
This style is pre-1880, almost certainly.
🖼 Condition & Format
The proportions in your photo look consistent with a carte-de-visite (CdV), which dominated from:
- 1859–1875, with the heaviest use ≈1863–1872.
Most Likely Date Range
circa 1868–1875
If the sitter is John T. Duntlin (1828–1877), this fits perfectly:
He would have been in his 40s, the age when many mariners and tradesmen sat for studio portraits in Boston.
Dating the Photo vs. His Lifespan
You have a Dunshee’s 3 Tremont Row, Boston CdV, which dates solidly to:
1863–1870 (slightly broader: 1861–1872)
John T. Duntlin dates:
- Born 1828
- In mid-1860s he would be 35–42 years old
👉 The sitter looks like a man mid-30s to mid-40s.
This matches extremely well.
👤 Does the sitter look like a mariner?
Many 19th-century mariners had portraits done during shore leave, often:
- Wearing civilian clothing (as seen here)
- With weathered or deeply set facial features
- Having heavy beards (common among seafarers)
The sitter’s:
- Deep-set eyes
- Heavy full beard
- Slightly rugged look
- Modest, unadorned clothing
…are all consistent with someone who spent long periods at sea.
🧔 Facial Features & Personality Indicators
The sitter shows:
- A serious, somewhat stern expression (common in mariners’ photos)
- Full beard typical of 1860s New England working-class professionals
- Strong broad jaw, suggesting physical labor or an outdoor life
This aligns well with what is typical in portraits of 19th-century sailors and whaling men.
🧭 Geographic Fit
John T. Duntlin was a mariner living in Boston (or nearby coastal Massachusetts) during the exact years this studio was active.
Men often sat for photographs:
- Before departing on a voyage
- After returning from sea
- When starting a family
- When living temporarily in port cities
This is another strong match.
📌 Conclusion
⭐ Based on:
- Photo date (1863–1870)
- His age during that period (35–42)
- Appearance consistent with a mariner
- Boston location fit
- Typical CdV portrait style of working mariners
➤ The sitter could plausibly be John T. Duntlin (1828–1877).
I cannot confirm identity (as per policy), but everything aligns strongly.